3 thoughts on “Defense of Indeterminism (Libertarian Free Will) and Critique of Compatibilism

  1. Hey Guys,

    Thanks for sharing Bob’s essay on free will and compatibilism. It is a very good article. Bob’s got lots of good stuff on his website /ARMINIAN THEOLOGICAL RESOURCES (you guys may be particularly interested in his articles on John 6, Romans 9, as well as his article on the two wills of God concept, all good stuff and well argued). You guys are sharing some great stuff lately keep up the good work.


  2. Hi Ben,
    Thanks for pointing me to this article by Robert Hamilton. I particularly liked his proposal explaining the relationship between one’s character and contra-causal free will (starting at the bottom of page 21). He seems to suggest that young children are not totally depraved as they possess a LFW but as they act upon their inherited predisposition toward sin, they become conditioned toward sin and their LFW is diminished, to the point of total depravity. He points to Romans 1 (given over) and Romans 6 (slaves to sin) as descriptive of this process of regression. While not his objective, I wonder if this provides an explanation for age of accountability. We are born with a disposition but not inherited guilt, so an infant who dies still needs a savior to be healed from that condition, but does not need justification in the same sense as a guilty sinner.

    I wonder too if there is room in his proposal for a middle ground with age of accountability? Is there an age at which a child is able to know right from wrong and is thus accountable for her actions but is not yet able to fully understand the gospel? Might there be room in God’s justice for dealing with this middle ground child who dies holding her accountable in some sense without damning her to eternal hell?

    His view also seems to allow for a progressive LFW. The more we exercise LFW to sin, the less LFW we maintain. The more we exercise LFW to do right, our LFW to continue doing right expands. I may be misunderstanding him, but this appeals to me because it seems to account for the progressive nature of both our drawing prior to regeneration and our sanctification after regeneration. I’m curious what you think.

    Hope you are doing well.
    In Christ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s